Skip to main content

New to optical heart rate monitors? You need to read this.

Garmin Forerunner 235

Time for an update

After nearly three years of wearing my Forerunner 230, I thought it was time to do an upgrade. For a while I had my eye on the Forerunner 235 but the price was never right. In the process, I had read multiple reviews and was pretty convinced it was the right watch for me... until I bought it.

After about a week of wearing it, I was utterly disappointed with the performance of the HR monitor and the battery life. And nothing I had read before warned me about it so I figured out it would make sense to write a piece in here so that other people may be aware before they take the plunge, especially now that the prices have dropped to under $170 as rumour has it that the 235 is on its way out.

Rather than writing a new review for an old watch, I'm going to concentrate on the HRM. First of all, yes, it is oh so convenient, especially if you've ever trained with a chest strap and you still have the the scars to prove it. But also, it's different technology and you need to understand it to make the most of it.

Chest strap vs Optical 

A chest strap measures your pulse via small electrical signals generated as your heart contracts. It then sends the information back to a connected device, usually, your smartphone. Optical monitors, on the other hand, use light (generally green) shone through the skin to detect blood flow through as bones, blood and skin reflect the light differently. The key takeout here is that both methods require a good connection (i.e. contact with the skin) to be effective.
That was my first disappointment. As a rule, I don't like wearing my watch too tight and my F230 was perfect in that sense. I could wear it whichever way I wanted. the F235 wouldn't take any reading accurately until I tightened it.

A tight watch is not enough

So I tightened the watch and still, my training session readings were all over the shop. Usually, it would record readings in Zone 5 as soon as I stepped out of the house. Enter disappointment number 2. No matter what pace I was doing, I was always overtraining as far as the Garmin was concerned. I had sessions where I wanted to scream and stamp on the bleeping watch! As it happens, it's not just a matter of wearing the watch tightly. You also need to ensure you're wearing it on a "flat" surface of your skin. For me, this meant wearing it about 2 fingers above where I normally wear any other watch. Other people claim it works best on the inside of the wrist. Some others say, it needs to be covered so the light bouncing from the skin doesn't get any external "noise".

The HR monitor will impact the battery life

So, Garmin tells us the battery life is about 11 hours of training or up to 9 days of normal wear... blah, blah, blah... the thing is, they phrase it in a way that you think, 9 days of normal wear? Yeah, that's what I'm used to with my current watch. Oh disappointment number 3... the optical HRM actually uses up battery like a demon if you combine 5 days of training and everyday heart rate tracking resulting in a measly 3/4 days' battery life.

In short

Once you get over all of this, the watch is actually fine. I'm learning to like it (not love it) and learning to train by heart rate zones.

Labels:
Location: Dublin, Ireland

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The hidden benefits of sport for teenagers

Following up from my last post , I have been giving some thought to the topic of teenagers and sport. Having a teenager in the house has taught me a thing or two about the way in which us parents, create a work ethic that will help them later in life, and the struggles we go through in order to turn actions into habits. Be the example We're all familiar with the old saying "Do as I say, not as I do" and it makes sense in a convoluted way, but not to a teenager. Imagine we tell them to get off the phone/tablet/Playstation and go to bed early, but they see us staying up till midnight browsing Facebook in bed. It sounds hypocritical, right? To a teenager, this feeling is amplified tenfold. If, on the other hand, we get proper rest, if we are commited to training, to fueling properly and we can show the results consistently, there's a better chance of the message sticking in their minds. Responsibility is personal When my son was younger, we would always mak...
Post a Comment
Read more

Short term goals vs long term vision

Why did you start running? We all start running for a reason. For some people, the motivation is to lose weight, for some others the is to gain fitness to do other sports. There is of course the love of running as a sport in itself but I don't think I've ever met anyone who one day just laced up, went out and was converted. There's always something ahead in the distance that pulls you. That's the inital goal. The pits of short term goals Say you take up running in January to lose some weight after the excesses of December. You religiously get out 3 or 4 days a week to do 4 miles and after a couple of months you hit your weight target. Then what? The initial goal is achieved and there's no incentive to keep on running so, instead of 4 times a week, you now run twice a week. Instead of 4 miles you run 3, then 2... See the pattern? There has to be more than immediate objectives to keep you going. Otherwise, there are too many forks on the road, too many deci...
Post a Comment
Read more

One week later

Last Sunday I ran the Great Ireland Run in Phoenix Park. It was the first time I've raced so close after a marathon so I wasn't too sure how the legs would be. The original plan was to run it as an easy race and enjoy the experience... yeah right! The closer it got to the day the more I started thinking maybe aim to run it under 55 minutes, maybe a bit faster but definitely not faster than 50. Anyway, race day arrived and once I was in Phoenix Park I decided sod it! Run it like a proper race  and see what it feels like. Go hard or go home! I started relatively slow but by the time I was passing the 6km mark I was still feeling strong so sped up to full tilt. In the end I ran just 12 seconds outside my PB of 46:06 but I have to say, I'm quite pleased with it. I just need to find another 10km race to finish that business...
Post a Comment
Read more